Are Catholics Wrong: Protestant Convert to Catholic Church header image 2

On Voting Your “Conscience”

October 21st, 2008 · 2 Comments

I have truly wanted to avoid making political statements on my blog. Partly because I am so disgusted by the whole political scene this election cycle that my blood pressure simply cannot take paying close enough attention to have an opinion informed enough to blog on it. Although lest anyone take me to task for failing in my citizenly duty, I have formed an opinion of sufficient depth to cast an educated vote. However, I heard it said once too often in very recent days, that someone was “going to vote their conscience” meaning they were going to vote third party rather than for one of the two men who will be our next president. (God help us.)

Let me be clear. I do not support either major candidate for the presidency. I have disliked McCain and his politics for as long as I can remember. I have disliked Obama and his politics for not quite as long. Nevertheless, I cannot cast my vote for someone who is campaiging on a promise to pass legislation that will surely increase the number of abortions in this country. I am not a one issue voter, but Obama’s absolutely uncompromising stance on abortion including voting against protecting babies born alive, and partial birth abortions, etc. totally disqualifies him for dog catcher much less POTUS.

But I digess. Back to voting third party. Unless a third party candidate is on the ballot in enough states to win an electoral majority and ideally in all 50 states (and yes, I know how hard that is to accopmlish for a third party candidate) they are simply not only not going to win. Furthermore, they are not prepared to govern if they do win.

The Constitution Party candidate (the one I have heard most often as the favored third party choice…although, he is not my particular temptation in the third party realm), Chuck Baldwin, is currently on the ballot (not as a write-in) in states constituting 318 electoral votes. That leaves 220 electoral votes that he absolutely cannot get. You need 270 to win.

So to be clear here, all Obama and McCain have to do TOGETHER is get 48 electoral votes in the states where Baldwin is on the ballot and he cannot win. Can’t. You think that Obama isn’t going to take 55 electoral votes in California? Or that Texas (34 electoral votes) isn’t going to McCain? That’s the reality.

And let’s just suspend reality for a minute and ask, “How is a third party candidate, that doesn’t even have the depth of support to get on the ballot in all 50 states going to govern in the event he actually got elected?” The whole idea of accumulating and spending “political capital” is a very real one and a third party candidate wouldn’t have ANY to start with.

I think that third party candidates for President help foster the notion that the most important vote we make is the one for President and that the only way we have to influence politics is with our vote. Meadow muffins. We’ve got a lot of options available to us. We can build a new party by doing the hard work necessary to get local people on the ballot and building from there, NOT by starting at the top and working down. We can have fund-raisers and talk to our neighbors for the the entire 4 years between presidential elections so that there is a base to build from. We can support the special interests that we care the most about with our hard earned money. We can write those people we do elect and send letters to the editor and hold our elected officials accountable ALL of the time and not just the 6 months before a presidential election.

It’s not our presidential vote that we “throw away.” It’s all the time between elections that is thrown away when we could have been working and investing some of our OWN political capital so that we aren’t faced with a choice of the lesser of two evils. If we are faced with a choice of the lesser of two evils, I don’t think that voting thrid party is the way to assuage our conscience. It’s how we use our time and money between elections that will truly fix our conscience.

I’m guilty too.


Tags: Perspective and Pontification · Pro-Life · Politics

 Subscribe to Comments


2 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Kelly // Oct 21, 2008 at 3:05 pm

    I am considering voting 3rd party because my state is a strong McCain state, so I am probably not helping Obama by not voting for McCain. I see higher levels of 3rd party votes as sending a message of voter dissatisfaction. I would not consider voting 3rd party in a swing state or an Obama state, and I still haven’t really decided what I will do there.

    I have also voted for pro-life Democrats at the local and state level as a way of encouraging the Democratic party to move away from the pro-choice platform.

    I do agree with you in general, and you give a lot of food for thought.

  • 2 Sister Spitfire // Oct 22, 2008 at 11:24 am

    Thanks Kelly. May God bless you as you discern the best course of action for you. I wish it was easy!!

Leave a Comment